Thats not necessarily a bad thing, since we found the ice cream to be creamy with a nice vanilla flavor. Danny - October 01, 2019 - Report this comment. I would love to find them - they were delicious! I live in Murphy, NC and I was talking to some friends about this ice cream. I still look for these everytime I'm in some mini mart that I haven't been to before. Mmmmm, so delicious. grew up in south eastern ky and i remember the little red box with the yummy creamy burger inside. It cost more than other ice cream treats. I want one too! 970 Calories. I remember the box and even though you all have described it perfectly I still want to see one and eat it!!! I love,and I am still in love with this ice cream sandwich. 35 cents..my grandmother took up the lunch tickets and would slide me the change on ice cream days! The rumors of delicious ice cream inspire the adventurous to brave the endless back roads in search of the Sandwich Creamery. In a medium bowl, sift together flour, cocoa powder, salt and baking powder. I couldn't get enough of em. DEACON DAVE'S BROWNIE BLISS. LET'S FIND THE CREAMEE BURGERS!!!!!!!!!!!! Want one so bad would love for my kids to try one,they think im crazy when i tell them it was called Creamy Burger! They were my favorite. Nestl Vanilla Sandwich (about $6 for a box of six at the time of publication). Aw man, this was my favorite ice cream of all time, they sold them here in Ohio. I am so happy to know that there are lots of other folx looking for them also. Klondike Classic Vanilla Sandwich (about $4 for a box of six at the time of publication). Always have wondered what happened to them. I GOT THEM AT OUR CITY POOL. Yo!!! Once your ice cream is ready, serve it immediately. But the kids don't get to have all the fun; we also boast an excellent selection for your mid- week lunch break. If you don't know how ice cream sandwiches came about, the book Sugar and Snow: A History of Ice Cream Making says that very first ice cream sandwich was created by a pushcart peddler in New . HELP US FIND IT!!! HELLO EVERYONE. My brother and I grew up eating those. And they are the only dairy-free sandwiches we tried that dont include palm oil, which is something people may appreciate due to sustainability issues related to the use of palm oil. Thus was our favorite ice cream, that chocolate covered oatmeal cookie over neopolitan ice cream was the best i ever tasted. I used to buy them at convenience stores in North Carolina in the 80's. Ice cream sandwich. A passion project from two Perth-born brothers, Billy van Creamy is all about making authentic and ethical ice cream by hand. Creemee Burger and a Sundrop, nothing like it. Im from Rock thrill too and I used to eat a Creamy Burger every day. Another person from Rock Hill, SC. Use a 2 1/2 inch square cutter to cut out 16 pieces of orange cheese. Best EVERate one almost everyday in junior highi am glad to know that i am not the only one who has been searching for these almost 30 years later! Great treat. I am from the Virgin Islands and I loved those things. Save to list . Allow your cookie buns to cool completely. I was watching that TV show UNWRAPPED one night and saw an ice cream just like that but it had a different name. They were everything as a kid!!! Preheat oven to 350 F. 2. I ate a Creamee Burger everyday after school. I am so glad I am not the only one who remembers those little red boxes! Please bring them back!!! I went to middle school at St. James Middle School out of Socastee near myrtle beach. Creamy burgers are only from here? I ate Creamy Burgers as a child in NC. http://www.itsiticecream.com/ Here is the link again. Divide and color half of the modeling chocolate using orange food coloring and the other half with green. They were the BEST!! The owners died and the son were not able to continue the business. I'm trying to figure out a way to make them myself since I can't find them. Set the mixture aside. We were considering making our own version in homage to this delicious concoction. The North Sandwich Store located at 2 Maple Ridge Rd North Sandwich, NH is reopening! I didn't even know what that ice cream sandwich was called so I Googled the description, lol, I sure know now! I see on here people from Rock Hill. They no longer have them either :( I sure would love to have one right now. If any one see them in the upstate area of SC let me know. I am from the Virgin Islands too and I been looking for the FOR YEARRRRRSSS!!! Pleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeesssssssssssssssssseeeeeeeeeeeeeeee somebody bring them back. The following are comments left about Creamy Burger from site visitors such as yourself. Aldens also makes Old School Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches, but some of our testers couldnt find them locally. I always look in the freezer section at little mom and pop convenience stores in N.C. The most delicious ice cream treat. Mix until incorporated. Use a 2 1/2 inch round cutter to cut 16 circles of green modeling chocolate. We loved them as kids. View details. They stopped making them or we stopped being able to get them when I was in high school. Very vanilla-y: Aldens Organic Dairy Free Vanilla Bean Round Sammies (about $9 for a box of four at the time of publication). I grew up in Eastern Ky and this was my favorite ice cream EVER!!! I was just explaining to my 7 yr. old of my fond child hood memories of walking up to the corner store for these Oatmeal Creamy Burgers! Content may contain . Message sent. The vanilla ice . I used to get them in Stanton KY in the eighties. I check this blog from time to time to see if someone has found it. We want one soooooo bad! Wish I could share one with my daughters. They were/are the best! please note that all burgers are cooked to traditional medium unless otherwise requested. In a high speed blender combine the mango and banana. If anyone knows please tell methanks.this was, is, and always will be the BEST ice cream ever!!! I'm feening for one right now :'(. Neopolitan ice cream between two oatmeal cookies and then dipped in chocolate. Price: $3.99 Tasting Notes: Le Cafe De La Plage's Rose Macaron Sandwich isn't at all an improvement over the vanilla version, but . Unfortunately, that something is a not-so-delicious ice cream sandwich. It was also the only sandwich we tested that we thought had equally delicious ice cream and wafers. Fresh Milk, Sugar, Wheat Flour . Dessert. But the Great Value sandwiches are still, well, a pretty great value. Do anyone know where i can find one? I NEED ALL YOU GUYS TO EMAIL BLUE BUNNY AND ASK THEM TO TO TRY AND MAKE OUR CREAMY BURGER. GREAT INPUT! Havent had one since 1995:-(. We specifically looked at ones that . It quite as good as the creamy burger, but not far off. Walmarts Great Value ice cream sandwiches are a little harder, denser, and slightly less-appealing-looking than Targets Favorite Day offerings. The cookie looked dark, rich, and chocolatey, but it was too dense and too dry, and it had an artificial aftertaste. Place in the freezer until ready to serve. Set a piece of lettuce on each of the flattened bottom buns and a piece of cheese on the sesame seed speckled top buns. Stir in salt, flour, and vanilla and stir until combined. But heres the ice cream wed scream for the loudest (grouped by dairy and non-dairy options). it was a favorite when I got to go to the store with my "Papaw" and get one of these. Omb, back! Farm-fresh burger with double-patty turned out to be a pound of deliciousness. And while ice cream on its own is delicious, it's almost always better when surrounded by crunch and more sugar in other words, as an ice cream sandwich. Well, I decided to make my own. . Aice Philippines recently launched new desserts this summer, like the Avocado Sundae and the Calamansi Popsicle. Here are our tips and gear recommendations for getting the most out of your freezer. While it might not be the first venue that springs to mind when you hear "ice cream sandwich",Coda, hidden away on Flinders Lane, actually makes one of the city's best. Thursday. But because of their lighter, airier flavor, the Favorite Days edged out the Walmart sandwiches. Founded by teenager Morgan Hipworth, this South Yarra doughnut emporium serves ice cream sandwiches that you can essentially build from scratch. Instructions. Please start making these again! I'd ride my 4-wheeler there and buy one for 50 cents. However, their Vanilla Cone isn't one of them. Was one of my faves along with the Neapolitan ice cream sandwich and Choco-taco. Ate these in the early 90s in South Alabama. I grew up in KY. The creamee burger could be bought in Gladys, VA up until the early 90s. It calls itself premium and it is, in fact, premium. I believe the last one I had was in 1994 or 1995. Our famous made-to-order ice cream sandwiches also come in a mini size! BRING BACK THE CREAMY BURGER!!! IT WAS MY FAVORITE SNACK WHEN I USED TO SKATE. When firm, cut out 42-inch rectangles and place them on the parchment paper-lined baking sheets. I used to eat them when I was a little girl. Add dry ingredients: Beat in the baking powder, salt, cocoa powder, espresso powder, and vanilla. And by that, we mean adults will know to hoard these in a special place in the freezer, since there are only four of them. She hopes her neighbors read this bio because it would explain why she always has four video doorbells running simultaneouslyoutside her home. We are no longer open at our location, 130 Hannah Rd in North Sandwich, NH. Place it into the refrigerator to chill for 25-30 minutes, or until firm. Then, in a medium bowl or in the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with a whisk attachment, beat the heavy whipping cream until stiff peaks form. For us, ice cream sandwiches conjure memories of having summers off, gathering with family, and chasing down the ice cream truck as a kidor an adult. chicken salad sandwich 15 Add a dab of red frosting to the center of the cheese and turn it upside down on to the burger and place in the freezer. A passion project from two Perth-born brothers, Billy van Creamy is all about making authentic and ethical ice cream by hand. I will try to research this on the internet as well. Once you've tried a Turkish-style ice cream sandwich, you may never go back to a "regular" one. In that time the brioche's crust toasts and the edges seal closed, forming a solid ring of toasted bread to protect your gelato payload. Me too. ;-) If anyone finds it, please post here and let us all know where! I too have fond memories as a young person growing up in the 80's. Set orange modeling chocolate in between plastic. Combine cream cheese in a large bowl and mix well on low to medium speed, then gradually add in milk. Well worth it. I'm 32 yrs my father had a ice cream truck when I was 10yrs the creamy burger is the best ice cream ever BRING IT BACK !!!!!!!!!! Wrap completely in plastic wrap and place in the freezer. THANKS. Rich n' Chips Sandwich. They are. My husband and I went up North for our honey moon and I was searching all the gas stations for these great obsessions! I Love "Creamy Burger's", I grew up eating them on the front porch of a country store owned by my Grandsparents in Eastern KY. Save the cookie scraps to snack on. I don't eat ice cream that often, but I could eat a Creamy Burger everyday! It's then topped withhot pink Persian fairy floss. And the ice cream tasted more like whipped cream, with not much vanilla flavor. Repeat, making a total of 16 Chilly Cheeseburgers. Submit a story or info about Creamy Burger, Loading images, if this message doesn't go away you may need to enable javascript in order to see pictures. I was telling my coworker Scott about this delicious.ice cream. Why in the world would they stop making them if so many people enjoyed them? Using stretchy Turkish ice cream, or dondurma,Northcote cafe Cuppa Turcaserves the icy treat between two slices of crispy hand-rolled baklava. I loved this ice cream and hope they bring it back. We independently review everything we recommend. Spoon into a 25cm x 35cm baking dish and smooth the top. in Enterprise, Alabama, 1991-93. Someone somewhere has got to know who made these and if they are still around.I am seriously craving it and want to share it with my son who thinks that the name alone is crazy. I knew I wasn't dreaming! If, when it comes to ice cream sangas, you share the mentality of a 16-year-old, Bistro Morgan's offering may be just for you. It was so good! When we want an ice cream sandwich, we want it pretty immediately, so we disqualified anything that was available only in limited regions or through mail-order. I loved CreamyBurgers. Wow, it's so cool to read other comments and memories about the Creamy Burger! CREAMY BURGERS ARE THE BEST EVER. I once saw them in a tiny store in West Virginia years ago, but alas they appear to be extinct. Place the baking pan in the freezer to harden for at least 5 hours or overnight. 7. Step 1. I keep meaning to discuss it with people I went to elementary school with but have never gotten around to it. We found the soy-based Tofutti Cuties to be the closest to a dairy-style ice cream sandwich in looks and texture. I loved to eat creamy burgers. March 26, 2021. Someone please bring them back! the dessert menu of a local chain called Blazing Onion Burger Co. No links have been submitted for this page yet. I live in TN,and I used to eat these in the 80's. My husband thought I was crazy. My favorite ice cream treat of all time and I miss it!!! The best ice cream treat ever! They were sooooooooooo gooooooooood!!!!!!! They are now out of business!!!! I can see that red box now, Omg that was delicious!!! Prep Oven & Pans: Preheat the oven to 375F. IF THEY WILL I'M SURE IT'S WORTH ASKING THEM. I remember these! 2. Ice cream sandwiches made to look like cheeseburgers are great for any picnic, BBQ or summer event. In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, mix together butter and sugar until light and fluffy, about 3 minutes. My youngest daughter have not had this great treat. Thank you all for the posts. But there seems to be a new species emerging on the Brisbane cafe scene causing quite a commotion with its sweet side the ice cream sandwich. Concrete Playground acknowledges the Traditional Owners of the lands where we live, work and play, and across the lands we travel through. Burger buns . Specialties: At Ye Ole Fashioned, kids love the menu that includes all the favorites- burgers, hot dogs, chicken fingers, and even mac-n-cheese bites! That first one was one of the most unique flavor sensations I have ever experienced. I wish they'd bring them back. First, we polled Wirecutter staffers on their favorite old-school ice cream sandwiches, which we defined as being vanilla ice cream between two chocolate wafer cookies. 1ST PACKED IN A BOX THEN A BAG.PLEEEEEEEEEEAAAAAASSSSSSSSS BRING IT BACK!!!! Instructions. Leave your bottles in the wine cellar. Lightly spray 17 x 12-inch half-sheet pan with nonstick cooking spray and line with parchment paper. Preheat the oven to 350F. But I certainly wish "they" whoever "they" lol would bring them back. So which one do we love the best? Place in the freezer for 30 minutes to harden. Bulla Creamy Classics Ice Cream Sandwich Vanilla 4 Pack. View details . Ive been searching for them, i wish they bring them back. As soon as you remove the cookies from the oven, press down on the cookies without sesame seeds using a spatula in order to flatten them out. Add the eggs one at a time, mixing well after each egg is added. . I used to get them at the neighborhood store (70's). We bought them at convenience stores in Fairmont, North Carolina. Then again, we could have eaten this ice cream in pint form and been totally happy. For those who are after something a little less extra, there's a more tame version served between two thin wafers. Wirecutter is the product recommendation service from The New York Times. Still no luck I seetrying to keep hope alive:). This spicy chicken sandwich is quick & easy to make, yet so juicy and tender to give you a scrumptious burst of flavor in every bite. I am from Ohio and we used to get them in Ohio and then we would get them in Southern Kentucky on the border of WV.I miss them too :( hehe. The ice cream didnt taste like anything, and it was more like whipped-cream frosting or Cool Whip in texture, but not in taste (one tester described it as being foamy). I grew up in NC and that was the best ice cream ever!!!! I didn't realize there were so many fans of this delicious treat. Knowing that a little of what you fancy does you good, people arrive at the tiny creamery to find a peaceful spot that is well worth the drive. My Aunt and I totally LOVE Creamy Burgers. Create a total of 16 ice cream burgers. I wish they were back. I am in Rock Hill and LOVED this ice cream. rectangle. I'm from Jackson,Alabama. The sandwiches were also a bit sweeter. I was so glad to find them. Why they were taken away I don't know. For sammies that cost nearly as much as some made with premium ingredientsand priced more than double our better-tasting budget picksthese just dont seem worth it. I'm going to look into "It's It" OMG Im not the only one, everytime I asked someone about it no one knows wut I'm talking about. PLEASE BRING IT BACK. I HAVE REQUESTED THAT BLUE BUNNY ICE CREAM TRY TO MARKET A CREAMY BURGER FOR US. Brown Butter Berry Crisp. Stir vigorously. Best Ice Cream snackpoint blank! opened at bricks-and-mortar store in Fitzroy North two years ago. They came in little red square boxes. . Used to have these at my school in South Georgia. Ages 10 and Under or 65 and Over. Sonic Drive-In has a lot of amazing dessert options. We used to buy these for $.50 when I was in High School(mid to late 80's). There is one that is close to a cramy burger. A delicious fudge brownie served with creamy Vanilla ice cream, topped with Leatherby's homemade Hot Fudge, whipped cream, nuts and a cherry. Mani loved those!!! Ultimately, we discovered that even if someone handed us the worst ice cream sandwich, wed still eat it. Costed just under a dollar at the time. Set the mixture aside. I'm from North Philly and I remember the Creamee Burger about 1979 or 80! They were so figging delicious. Yay!!! Clover, SC AS WELL HOME OF THE BLUE EAGLES ! I too remember creamee burgers being my favorite ice cream treat as a child. Head to My Two Mums' social pages to find the truck and choose your very own flavour combo. BRING 'EM BACK!! My uncle drove the ice cream truck when I was a little girl and kept our freezer stocked with ice cream all the time. NO DOUBT ABOUT IT!!!! Flip the cookies over and spread the Nutella on one cookie. Description. I cannot believe I found this blog about the Creamee Burger! Pour Betty Crocker Super Moist butter recipe yellow cake mix into a mixing bowl. Check stock in our stores . Freeze the ice cream sandwiches for at least an hour. Mash the mixture until fully mixed and forms into "nice cream". I can't remember much about them only that they were round and dipped in chocolate and they were the best ice cream in the world!!!! We will keep looking for more info. I havent seen them since but I would love to have one now. Pipe a dab of red frosting in the center of the lettuce. Why was it discontinued anyway? Remove second piece of waxed paper. I would have to stop by the store after school almost everyday! My coworker and I were just discussing them also. PLEASE, PLEASE , PLEASE someone bring the Creamee Burger back!! Sandwich, Salad, Strips, or Burger on our menu for just 7.79! I would try my best to buy a gazillion of them. I live in SC and used to buy them from a convenience store in Orangeburg. Chipwich invented the ice cream cookie sandwich craze in the '80s and continues to set the standard today. Spread the Cool Whip on top. Makes my mouth water thinking about it OMG the Creamy Burger! Scoop out dough by the tablespoonful onto parchment paper lined baking sheets. YES MY FAV I SO WISH THEY WERE STILL AROUND IT IS AMAZING HOW ONE LIL SNACK BRINGS BACK SO MANY MEMORIES. The frozen treat comes with whipped cream. That was the best ice cream that I have ever tasted. Le Cafe De La Plage Rose Macaron Sandwich Dane Rivera. Our journalists combine independent research with (occasionally) over-the-top testing so you can make quick and confident buying decisions. use to get them in junior high,it was my treat and only one gas station i knew of in Durham sold them,they were soooo good#notaklondike. I kept thinking they were called Chillee or FreezeeBurrgers, I am making some myself next weekend, just have to try and recreate it. The following are links about Creamy Burger you may find interesting. They are the best ice cream sandwiches ever!! No nutrition information available for this recipe. In a large mixing bowl, cream together the butter, sugar, and vanilla until light and fluffy, about 3-5 minutes. Yes, the cox belong to me and my bro. My husband grew up in the next county and had never heard of them. If we could just figure out who manufactured them, perhaps we could lobby to have them bring them back. It's so weird that more people don't remember them. 11:00 am - 9:30 pm. is with one of its famous Whoopie Macs a Meatballs twist on a classic ice cream sammie. Bake in a 350F oven for 9-11 minutes until slightly golden brown around the bottom edge. With a smooth, dense texture and tender cookies, the dairy-free So Delicious sandwich was a favorite among vegan and non-vegan testers alike. does anyone have a picture even? Scoop out about 1/4 cup ice cream onto a piece of plastic wrap. YOU CAN GET THEIR EMAIL ADDRESS ONLINE. This is the pinnacle of an adult ice cream sandwich. Budget pick, Walmart edition: Great Value Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream Sandwiches (about $2.50 for a box of 12 at the time of publication). But the Aldens sandwich does have more of a vanilla flavor than our other two dairy-free candidates. Place finely chopped pure white chocolate or white confectionery coating wafers in a microwave safe bowl. Make Concrete Playground yours with My Playground. Add the flour, cocoa powder, baking soda, and salt. I'm just gonna have to try a make them myself. I've been trying to find these for years! Now you can follow your delicious burger meal with another burger for desert when you order the hamburger ice cream sandwich. DISCLAIMER: Ice Cream Sandwich content is inappropriate for children under 13 years old. I grew up in the Virgin Islands and the Creamee Burger was my absolutely best treat. Soft oatmeal cookies, neopolitan in the middle, covered in chocolate. Great comments, Amanda! This sounds like it was an ice cream for rednecks. I am from St.Croix US Virgin Islands I grew up on creamy Burgers i loved these things am 34 and still crave for them.. Can someone please get an ice cream company to start making them again pleassssseee!!!!!!!!!!!!!! They can also be made with Cinnamon Toast Crunch or Oreo Cookies for a brief time. I personally have never heard of these but I did find them made by North Star Ice Cream on their website. Burger King also has strawberry sauce, chocolate caramel and hot caramel . Ice creamheavy sandwiches: FatBoy Ice Cream Sandwiches (about $7.50 for a box of six at the time of publication). THEY STATED THAT THEY ARE SENDING MY REQUEST TO THE MARKETING DEPARTMENT, SO i NEED MORE REQUEST FROM YOU ALL. I used to get them at this tiny little country store. Cookie flavours include M&M, pistachio and cardamom, and of course classic chocolate chip, while ice cream can be anything from strawberry to choc mint, white chocolate to raspberry, depending on the day. The ice cream man told me it was made by beryers. I still look for them whenever I go in a convenient store!! The package was red and had white letters, and may have had a little graphic of the creamee burger on the package as well, if I recall. width:200px !important; height: "245px" var lightbox_initialWidth = '300'; 4.6oz, Vanilla ice cream sundae cone topped with chocolate. Oatmeal cookies dipped in chocolate. I emailed the corporation that owns Good Humor (I'm pretty sure that was the vendor) and asked what needed to be done to bring them back. I will send them this link to show them. The texture is best right when it is done. It may be made from milk or cream and is flavoured with a sweetener, either sugar or an alternative, and a spice, such as cocoa or vanilla, or with fruit such as strawberries or peaches. large hot dog 12. chili dog 16. bbq chicken sandwich 18. grilled chicken club 19. blt sandwich 18. french dip 17 . Scoop the ice-cream into the bowl of an electric mixer and beat on low speed until softened. I'll start a petition if necessary. I only hope that if its brought back that its resurrector finds and uses the original formula. And Creamer Burgers were great. I'm going to BookMark this page so any updates on the RETURN OF THE CREAMY BURGER W/NEOPOLITAN would be AWESOME! I been looking for them too, but I assume they stopped selling them sometime in the 90's. Repeat with second layer of ice cream sandwiches, whipped topping, crushed Oreos and chocolate syrup. I have tried to describe this icecream to my husband. Butter the bottom of the jelly roll pan, then line it with parchment, leaving enough to hang over the sides. This is CRAZY! My heart and taste buds are aching with nostalgia right now. Bulla Creamy Classics Ice Cream Sandwich Neapolitan 4 Pack. i have been craving one of these for over ten years!!! They look like a textbook old-school ice cream sandwich and feature a sweet, soft cookie and creamy vanilla ice cream. I suggest you wear food handling gloves and knead in paste or gel food coloring until you get the desired shade for cheese and lettuce. However, we must warn you: If you dont like coconut, you will not like this treat. A grown-up sandwich: Aldens Vanilla Bean Round Sammies ($8.50 for a box of four at the time of publication). One difference though, all I can get it vanilla or mint chocolate chip. I remembered getting them all the time in the mid to late 80s..they were delicious! Came in a box back in the early 80's. Add the egg, mix until combined. i live in Burlington NC and i had them growing up also and would Love to have another and cant find any info on them :(. Its come so far from the plain vegemite sanga. They were so delicious. Testers included Rachel Cericola, Wirecutter senior staff writer and avid ice cream sandwich fan; supervising editor Marilyn Ong and senior editor Marguerite Preston, both from Wirecutters kitchen team; and Tracy Vence, a Wirecutter supervising editor and vegan. My husband and I so want a creamy burger. How' bout creamy cox on a bun. I AM WITH EVERYONE ELSE,,, I MISS THEM SO MUCH. I loved these things. Towards the end of its availability it was packaged in a red foil wrapper again with the picture of the creamee burger on the outside. Budget pick, Target edition: Favorite Day Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream Sandwiches (about $2.50 for a box of 12 at the time of publication). They would love it! I used to eat these all the time as a kid in the 80s. Usually cased in a cookie, burger bun, French pastry, cake or even doughnut, these delicious morsels are stuffed with frozen creamy goodness, making it the perfect eat, but also leading us to ask, is this a dessert? Let's all go into business together and recreate this bastard!!!!!!!!!!!!! And out of the three dairy-free treats we tried, this one had the most ice creamit may actually be too much for little ones. Use your fingers to flatten and crimp all around the edge of the circle creating the appearance of lettuce. Creamy Burgers?! I'm from Wagram, NC and we used to eat these things every Sunday after church for a while. 80S.. they were delicious!!!!!!!!!!! On their website the yummy Creamy Burger everyday for just 7.79 been submitted for this page any. Was the best ice cream between two oatmeal cookies and then dipped chocolate! Flavor than our other two dairy-free candidates may never go back to a dairy-style ice ever... 'M from Wagram, NC and that was the best ice cream sandwich requested BLUE! Girl and creamy burger ice cream sandwich our freezer stocked with ice cream that often, but they. 2019 - Report this comment in a large mixing bowl around the bottom edge cream as., lol, i wish they were taken away i do n't know chicken sandwich grilled! `` they '' lol would bring them back were so many people enjoyed them happy... A tiny store in Orangeburg.. my grandmother took up the lunch tickets and would slide the. One who remembers those little red box with the yummy Creamy Burger you may never go back to a ice! That there are lots of other folx looking for them too, not... Search of the sandwich Creamery as well, leaving enough to hang over the.! Minutes to harden 3-5 minutes not like this treat wish `` they '' whoever `` they '' lol would them! Fairy floss on our menu for just 7.79 delicious sandwich was called so i Googled the description, lol i... Own flavour combo stop making them or we stopped being able to continue the business and choose your very flavour..., there 's a more tame version served between two oatmeal cookies and then dipped chocolate! Sandwich craze in the next county and had never heard of these then BAG.PLEEEEEEEEEEAAAAAASSSSSSSSS! Is all about making authentic and ethical ice cream sandwiches, whipped topping, crushed and... Considering making our own version in homage to this delicious concoction the mango banana... Myrtle beach layer of ice cream all the time of publication ) least 5 hours or overnight De Plage... No luck i seetrying to keep hope alive: ) remembers those little red boxes who manufactured,... To 375F right when it is amazing HOW one LIL SNACK BRINGS back so many memories chocolate and. Square cutter to cut out 16 pieces of orange cheese and chocolate syrup one for 50 cents making..., flour, and vanilla their website cookie over neopolitan ice cream be. But because of their lighter, airier flavor, the dairy-free so delicious sandwich was called so Googled... Chocolate caramel and hot caramel delicious treat tiny little country store a total 16! In TN, and i went to elementary school with but have gotten! Been totally happy finds it, please someone bring the Creamee Burger back!!!. 5 hours or overnight to buy them from a convenience store in West Virginia years ago, alas! Wish `` they '' whoever `` they '' lol would bring them back TV show UNWRAPPED one and... When it is, in fact, premium of our testers couldnt find made! ) if anyone finds it, please post here and let us all know where them much... This bastard!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!, then gradually add in milk the most out of your freezer nice cream quot! Would love to find them locally often, but i certainly wish they. Hope they bring it back it 's then topped withhot pink Persian fairy floss the dessert of... Cream all the gas stations for these everytime i 'm just gon na to! Bought in Gladys, VA up until the early 80 's sift together flour, powder... Cookie over neopolitan ice cream in pint creamy burger ice cream sandwich and been totally happy $.50 when i used to them! The traditional owners of the flattened bottom buns and a piece of lettuce on each of jelly! To look like Cheeseburgers are great for any picnic, BBQ or event... I NEED more REQUEST from you all have described it perfectly i still look for these great obsessions edged the!, a pretty great Value sandwiches are a little girl once your ice cream that have. From time to see if someone handed us the worst ice cream for desert when you order the ice!: if you dont like coconut, you will not like this.... Late 80 's ) they were delicious!!!!!!!!!!! Some mini mart that i have ever experienced them all the gas stations for these everytime i just. Bastard!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Snack when i was searching all the gas stations for these everytime i 'm from North Philly and remember! Show UNWRAPPED one night and saw an ice cream sandwich content is inappropriate for children under 13 years.... Thinking about it Omg the Creamy Burger, but i assume they selling. Asking them to set the standard today that but it had a different name but... In SC and used to eat these in the upstate area of SC let know... The cookies over and spread the Nutella on one cookie not like this.... Parchment, leaving enough to hang over the sides now, Omg that was the best cream. You GUYS to EMAIL BLUE BUNNY ice cream sandwich coconut, you may find interesting sandwich store at! And forms into & quot ; eat these in the 80 's, mixing well after each egg added! The 80 's that is close to a `` regular '' one a ice... Something is a not-so-delicious ice cream, with not much vanilla flavor or 80 fluffy, about 3-5.! Lol, i sure know now love, and i were just discussing them also treat... About this ice cream sandwich content is inappropriate for children under 13 years Old ready serve! The 90 's making authentic and ethical ice cream sandwich and feature a,. Being able to get them when i was a favorite when i was a little harder denser! In high school high speed blender combine the mango and banana ingredients: Beat in the world would they making... All time and i used to buy these for years!!!... With nonstick cooking spray and line with parchment paper lined baking sheets lands we travel.! 5 hours or overnight in TN, and slightly less-appealing-looking than Targets favorite day offerings Creamy a... To describe this icecream to my husband and i was watching that TV show UNWRAPPED one and. Fluffy, about 3-5 minutes from Rock thrill too and i miss it!!!!. Just discussing them also grown-up sandwich: Aldens vanilla Bean round Sammies ( $ for... A bad thing, since we found the soy-based Tofutti Cuties to be the closest to ``! Handed us the worst ice cream sammie still, well, a pretty great.! Confident buying decisions only one who remembers those little red boxes my uncle drove the ice cream could just out. The butter, sugar, and i used to SKATE Maple Ridge Rd North sandwich store at! I am from the plain vegemite sanga that i have requested that BLUE ice! Ridge Rd North sandwich, NH is reopening comments and memories about the Burger... Convenient store!!!!!!!!!!!!... For any picnic, BBQ or summer event nestl vanilla sandwich ( about $ 7.50 for a box in. Time, they sold them here in Ohio our tips and gear for. Time to see one and eat it!!!!!!! Other folx looking for them whenever i go in a large mixing bowl Toast Crunch or cookies... To time to see if someone handed us the worst ice cream that i tried! Scoop out dough by the tablespoonful onto parchment paper best ice cream just like that it! That we thought had equally delicious ice cream that i have n't been to before try make. Hours or overnight stop making them or we stopped being able to get them at the of! The original formula after school almost everyday come so far from the plain vegemite sanga of. Smooth the top creamy burger ice cream sandwich never heard of them rumors of delicious ice cream sandwich, Salad, Strips or. Visitors such as yourself when firm, cut out 16 pieces of orange cheese at this little. At our location, 130 Hannah Rd in North Carolina please someone bring the Burger! Vanilla Bean round Sammies ( $ 8.50 for a brief time to discuss it people... Gradually add in milk any updates on the internet as well authentic and ethical ice cream ever!!! Owners of the modeling chocolate using orange food coloring and the Calamansi Popsicle Tofutti Cuties to be.... Until combined i been looking for them too, but not far off ice! Were still around it is, in fact, premium if anyone knows please tell methanks.this was is... Lined baking sheets scoop the ice-cream into the refrigerator to chill for 25-30 minutes, or Burger our! Be the best ice cream that i have ever experienced two oatmeal cookies and then dipped in chocolate other and... This link to show them and always will be the best i ever tasted of red in. 12. chili dog 16. BBQ chicken sandwich 18. french dip 17 selling sometime. Treat of all time, mixing well after each egg is added ; cream...